Skip to main content

Telling QB stat exposes the hilarious irony in the Brock Purdy-Joe Burrow MVP race

ByZane Gelphman
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy has been called many things in his young career. While 49er faithful have embraced him as their franchise quarterback, other, more dismissive labels have included "Mr. Irrelevant," "system quarterback," and "game manager."

But in 2026, he is seemingly bucking those aliases and making a convincing case for the MVP. However, he's not the favorite. That honor belongs to Joe Burrow, who ironically may fit the mold Purdy has been forced into .

A recent stat hit social media, highlighting Burrow's reliance on safety valves. The graph showed quarterbacks' checkdown rates and EPA per checkdown. Burrow's checkdown rate was through the roof, higher than any other qualifying QB and roughly 6.0 percent higher than Purdy.

The graph paints Burrow as the safe, risk-averse quarterback that everybody thinks Brock Purdy is. Burrow's high checkdown volume makes sense when put into context. His running back, Chase Brown, has made a living off catching dinks and dunks from his QB.

Brock Purdy deserves more credit in the MVP conversation

That's not to say Burrow doesn't belong in the MVP conversation. What he's doing out in Cincinnati is truly special. But his gaudy numbers may be buoyed by a myriad of low-skill passes.

And lest we mention the fact that he has arguably the best wide-receiver tandem in the NFL in Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. The latter is easily on pace for the best season of his career.

Purdy's success has often been attributed to the wealth of talent around him. Christian McCaffrey out of the backfield is a Hall of Fame security blanket, while George Kittle and friends give him a wide array of weapons downfield.

Brock Purdy has done more with less in beat-up 49ers offense

But the beloved gunslinger has used this season to prove that he can produce no matter who is catching passes for him. With injuries to Mike Evans, Deebo Samuel, and exciting rookie De'Zhaun Stribling, he has proven to be the common denominator of the team's consistent success.

Whether it's with a clean pocket, under duress, or with a hampered receiving room, Purdy has battled all obstacles this season to lead the 49ers to an 8-1 first half. Meanwhile, Burrow has had his entire arsenal, and it's why the Bengals are 7-2 and lead the AFC North.

While Joe Burrow has inflated his numbers thanks to numerous safe throws, Purdy has had to earn his stripes on a weekly basis. Such factors must be taken into account at the end of the season when the MVP is decided.

Add us as a preferred source on Google