San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy had one of the better games of his NFL career on Sunday against the Dallas Cowboys. He inserted himself back into the MVP conversation even though the oddsmakers have him trailing Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow, which reveals a double standard between the two.
While Burrow certainly has the stats to back up his status as the MVP frontrunner after a great showing on Sunday night against the Pittsburgh Steelers, it’s interesting to note the fact no one holds it against him that he has great weapons on offense.
Burrow is obviously a great quarterback, but he has two of the best wide receivers in the game at his disposal in Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. No one views that as an asterisk on his numbers or his performance in the slightest.
Meanwhile, the last time Purdy was in the MVP conversation back in 2023, all of his detractors talked about how he had a great supporting cast and was simply a beneficiary of all the collected talent surrounding him.
Now, just a few years later, Purdy is winning games without his top receiver, Mike Evans, and he is getting the job done by throwing to young guys like Jordan Watkins or veterans who were literally scooped up days before like Keenan Allen. They’ve had so many injuries at receiver and still the offense is humming.
Of course, he does still have stars like Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle, and a resurgent Deebo Samuel who would help make things easier for any quarterback, but at least it’s not quite held against him the same way as it used to be.
Joe Burrow has elite weapons just like Brock Purdy, so...
So why is there this double standard?
Obviously, it has to do with the fact Burrow is the quintessential star quarterback. He was drafted No. 1 overall after winning the Heisman Trophy and winning a national championship in college at LSU. Plus, he’s got the looks of a movie star and the confidence to match it.
On the other hand, Purdy was taken with the very last pick in the NFL Draft and “dresses like a substitute teacher,” in the words of his head coach Kyle Shanahan. Some people just can’t accept the fact someone like Purdy has been able to have such success when he didn’t have the pedigree of others coming out of college.
We will see how the rest of the season plays out as Burrow may be tough to chase down in the MVP race. But it’s clear there’s still a lingering double standard between him and Purdy that doesn’t feel entirely fair.
