Skip to main content

Kyle Shanahan's trust in Jacob Cowing may come back to bite 49ers

He's taking a big risk.
ByNick San Miguel
Santa Clara, California, USA;  San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan looks on during the second half against the Las Vegas Raiders at Levi's Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Cary Edmondson-Imagn Images
Santa Clara, California, USA; San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan looks on during the second half against the Las Vegas Raiders at Levi's Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Cary Edmondson-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Special teams has not been as solid as it was last season for the San Francisco 49ers. They’ve made some tweaks which should improve things on the kick coverage side, but when it comes to punt returns, Jacob Cowing is not someone who inspires a ton of confidence.

Head coach Kyle Shanahan still trusts him, though, which could end up backfiring.

Shanahan was asked about Cowing at San Francisco’s practice in Colorado on Wednesday, and coach had the following to say: 

I’m confident in Cowing. Especially his return abilities. I don’t think we’ve gotten a ton of good looks. Haven’t got a lot of returns. I know our numbers are very bad in that area, but Cowing has the ability to be a very good punt returner. I hope he keeps getting more confidence and consistent at catching the ball.

That’s the right thing for Shanahan to say. He obviously wants to build up the confidence of a young player in the middle of the year, but Cowing has already muffed one punt this season against the Seattle Seahawks and nearly muffed another last week against the Dallas Cowboys but was able to hang onto it.

One cannot help but miss Skyy Moore a little bit after his performance as San Francisco’s returner last season. He did a good job and was probably the 49ers' best returner since Ted Ginn Jr.

Yet, they can’t bring Moore back, so it seems like Cowing is going to be the guy for now, although they could turn to some other potential options. Jordan Watkins returned punts in college at Ole Miss and actually took one to the house in his junior year. Deebo Samuel could be another option, too, since he has returned kicks over the years, so maybe those skills would transfer to punts.

49ers are on shaky ground with Jacob Cowing returning punts

If Cowing’s numbers don’t improve, the Niners may have to make a change. Back in 2024 when he was a rookie, Cowing returned 28 punts for 245 yards with a long of 30 yards and an average of 8.8 yards per return. This season, he’s returned seven punts for a total of 27 yards with a long of 13 yards and an average of 3.9 yards per return.

One doesn’t want to invoke the name Kyle Williams lightly, but 49ers fans know what having an unreliable punt returner can mean. Cowing is a young player who might feel the pressure in a big moment, especially during the playoffs, and cough the ball up.

That’s why Shanahan is taking a risk by not switching things up.

Going to Watkins feels like a natural move because he is having a good season as a receiver, and his confidence has to be high. Confidence seems like the biggest thing with returners, so they may as well put someone back there who has good vibes going rather than a player like Cowing who hasn’t had much go right for him this season.

Maybe Shanahan will be proven right, and his trust in Cowing will be justified. But if he muffs a punt in a big moment, then it will look like a pretty major blunder by Shanahan that he should have addressed sooner. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google