Skip to main content

Kaelon Black still has one key lesson to learn as Christian McCaffrey's understudy

The rookie could become CMC's successor... maybe.
ByZane Gelphman
San Francisco 49ers running back Kaelon Black
San Francisco 49ers running back Kaelon Black | Michael Zagaris/GettyImages

Running back Kaelon Black has been a revelation for the San Francisco 49ers this season. Following a year in which Christian McCaffrey was burdened with nearly 500 touches between the regular season and the playoffs, Black has been able to spell the Pro Bowler on a weekly basis.

With CMC on the wrong side of 30, it's easy to wonder if Black can eventually overtake him as the team's go-to rusher. But there is one lesson the rookie has yet to learn from his predecessor: pass catching.

In Sunday's win over the Dallas Cowboys, Black caught two passes, nearly doubling his season total.

His lack of work in the passing game isn't a new phenomenon. In his two years at Indiana, he only caught eight balls for 42 yards, though he did haul in 27 passes in his redshirt sophomore year at James Madison in 2023.

Kaelon Black is still not CMC's successor just yet... but he's getting there

Regardless, his receiving skills still need refining. His second catch, a minimal 2-yarder on first down, could've gone for a longer gain, but Black took an extra second to secure the pass before getting downhill.

It was a far cry from the crisp catch-and-run transitions fans are used to seeing out of CMC.

The former Hoosier has also caught a meager 55.0 percent of his targets, albeit a small sample size. By comparison, McCaffrey has a career 80.5 percent catch rate.

With McCaffrey's contract expiring at the end of 2027, decisions will need to be made. The bell cow is not getting any younger, and it's reasonable to believe that Kaelon will continue to steal more touches away from him.

But the rookie has yet to establish himself as a one-for-one replacement if San Francisco were to ever let CMC walk in free agency. His five receptions on the year are a far cry from McCaffrey's 40, and lest we forget to mention the fact that the latter now holds the Super Bowl-era record for the most receiving touchdowns by a running back.

Kaelon Black has been a slam-dunk draft pick for 49ers, regardless of his pass-catching development

It's clear Black has a long way to go to reach CMC-level receiving ability... but he's steadily improving.

Amid his first multi-reception game as a pro, he also made the highlight reel with his trucking of the Cowboys' Quinnen Williams in pass protection. Black feigned a handoff on a play-action pass and immediately rammed into the 303-pound defensive lineman, knocking him to the ground.

Regardless of whether Kaelon Black can turn into the second coming of Christian McCaffrey, he is making the 49ers look like geniuses for spending a Day 2 draft pick on him. His bruising run style combined with his commitment to improvement has the Niners set up for long-term success in the backfield.

Add us as a preferred source on Google