It feels like a yearly tradition for the San Francisco 49ers and the NFL Draft: Kyle Shanahan is going to pound the table for a running back in the mid rounds, and often quickly, that player will fail to produce and fall out of the head coach's good graces.
From Joe Williams in the current regime's first draft in 2017, to Trey Sermon, Ty Davis-Price, and Isaac Guerendo (not to mention later-round guys like Elijah Mitchell and Jordan James), the Niners haven't been shy about bringing in guys for the backfield.
But it finally appears that they found a real answer to the years-long project in former Indiana back Kaelon Black, whom the Niners took, you'd be surprised to know, in the third round of the 2026 NFL Draft.
The move was not well received at the time, with most draft pundits knocking San Francisco for once again over-drafting a running back.
The rookie proved his worth out of the gate, carrying the ball 14 times for 65 yards in his NFL debut against the Los Angeles Rams in Melbourne, and he has featured in all nine 49ers games so far this season, including double-digit carries the last three weeks.
Black is averaging a solid 4.5 yards per carry this season, while allowing the Niners to not lean on Christian McCaffrey to make the run game function. This has freed McCaffrey up to use his versatility, as he did in Sunday's win over Dallas.
49ers must use Kaelon Black as their primary rusher going forward
Black's rise should continue, as he's been just as good as CMC in yards per carry, while also proving himself to be a more successful runner, per Pro Football Reference's data (58.2 percent against McCaffrey's 53.9 percent).
This isn't to say McCaffrey can't still carry the ball or that Black should turn into the 49ers' bell cow the way that CMC has been since arriving in San Francisco. The rookie still has elements of his game to work on before that happens, most notably a fumble problem that never existed prior to this season.
But for this version of the 49ers, Black has to be a bigger part of the offense, and Shanahan needs to figure out creative ways to get both of his playmakers on the field at the same time more often. Not just two-back formations, but possibly using McCaffrey as a slot receiver to create mismatches, too.
It isn't clear whether Black is ready to be the guy in Shanahan's offense just yet, but in a season that's all about maximizing this roster as much as possible, the Niners need to focus more on Black as a runner in order to do just that.
