The SF 49ers have experienced some tough seasons where the end results never matched the hype, and here are the five toughest.
The 2020 SF 49ers were a case study for why teams are guaranteed nothing on paper until they actually play the games.
Months after falling just short in Super Bowl LIV, the 2020 Niners were projected by many analysts and pundits to get right back into the NFL championship game and compete with the team that beat them for the Lombardi Trophy in the first place, the Kansas City Chiefs.
Unfortunately, nothing of the sort happened.
A slew of injuries to head coach Kyle Shanahan’s squad decimated the roster, ultimately leading San Francisco to a 6-10 record that season and a last-place finish within the NFC West. Any hope for what had been dubbed as a “revenge tour” following the Super Bowl loss evaporated quickly.
Quite the definition of a disappointment.
But which ones were the worst? These following five seasons aren’t necessarily the worst SF 49ers teams of all time, as some years fans expected the Niners to be bad. And they often were.
No, instead, let’s look at five seasons where San Francisco had the hype but ultimately couldn’t deliver in what turned out to be major disappointments.
No. 5: 2020 SF 49ers (6-10)
Kicking off this list will be a year SF 49ers fans would like to forget.
No team in the league suffered more injuries, had more players on injured reserve or used more combinations of roster lineups than the 2020 Niners. The bad news truly started in Week 2 when San Francisco lost up-and-coming star EDGE Nick Bosa to a season-ending ACL tear. The injury progression worsened with other key losses, too, namely quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo and All-Pro tight end George Kittle missing significant time with injuries.
As for the offense, only fullback Kyle Juszczyk, right tackle Mike McGlinchey and left guard Laken Tomlinson managed to stay healthy for all 16 games. The defense, which still ranked in the top five in yards allowed, didn’t fare much better as far as health was concerned.
Coming off a 13-3 regular-season campaign and Super Bowl berth the season before, Shanahan’s squad limped (quite literally) to that 6-10 record and also had to deal with being ousted from Levi’s Stadium for the final month of the year because of Santa Clara County protocols in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic.
No wonder Shanahan phrased the 2020 season as “the most disappointing one” he endured.
It ranks No. 5 on our all-time list.
No. 4: 2007 49ers (5-11)
In 2005, the Niners were beginning the early stages of a rebuild under newly hired head coach Mike Nolan, who was looking to bring back the glory days of the franchise from the early 1970s when his father, Dick Nolan, was the team’s head coach.
Those first two years under Mike Nolan weren’t pretty, as the No. 1 pick from the 2005 NFL Draft, quarterback Alex Smith, struggled amid a roster lacking talent on both sides of the ball.
Yet that was expected to change in year three of Nolan and Smith’s tenure. San Francisco spent plenty of money during the offseason, luring in high-profile free agents like cornerback Nate Clements and safety Michael Lewis to bolster the back end of the defense, and the SF 49ers also ended up with one of the best linebackers to play the game, Patrick Willis, as well as a future stalwart offensive tackle, Joe Staley, in Round 1 of the 2007 draft.
Plus, the Niners were hoping Smith would finally showcase all the reasons why he was selected first overall two years earlier.
Alas, nothing of the sort happened.
Despite starting off 2-0, San Francisco would lose eight consecutive games to start the year 2-8 before eventually finishing 5-11. Smith suffered a shoulder injury in Week 4, and that led to ongoing conflicts between him and Nolan about the quarterback’s toughness.
And it also signaled the inevitable end of the forgettable Nolan era with the SF 49ers, which officially ended midway through the following year.
No. 3: 2010 SF 49ers (6-10)
One of the seemingly positive ramifications from the Niners moving on from Mike Nolan is it allowed assistant coach and Hall of Fame linebacker Mike Singletary to assume the reins in 2008 and into 2009.
2009 seemed to be good enough, as Singletary’s squad managed to finish with a .500 record — the first non-losing season for San Francisco since 2002 — which suggested 2010 would be the year in which the SF 49ers finally got back into the playoffs.
Patrick Willis and Joe Staley had both solidified themselves as stars. Running back Frank Gore was a star, too, and the Niners were favored by many to win the NFC West that season.
Well, no. Not exactly.
While San Francisco’s defense showed some signs of improvement, there was a clear disconnect on offense. Offensive coordinator Jimmy Raye earned no praise from the fanbase before he was fired in the middle of the season, and Singletary’s lack of game-planning and development ultimately forced the SF 49ers to boast an offense that finished 24th in scoring that year.
And the ominous disappointment began when the Niners started the season with a 0-5 record, essentially putting them out of playoff contention before the halfway point of the year was reached.
Singletary was fired just before Week 17, yet the pieces were in place to build a championship contender.
So, that was a plus.
No. 2: 2014 SF 49ers (8-8)
It’s somewhat odd to consider a .500 San Francisco team a disappointment, especially one ranking at No. 2 on the list.
But after the team made it to three NFC Championship games, winning one of them and getting to the Super Bowl the three years prior, it’s hard not to classify 2014 as a disappointment.
These were, of course, the years under head coach Jim Harbaugh, and he deserved a lot of credit for taking an underachieving-yet-talented team in the wake of Mike Singletary’s departure and turning it into a true smashmouth, defensively dominant squad much like Singletary envisioned.
In 2014, however, things began to fall apart.
While the roster was beginning to show signs of cracks under then-general manager Trent Baalke, it was Baalke and the front office’s rifts with Harbaugh that became the storyline. Various reports cited tension between Harbaugh and the front office, which was siding with Baalke, and the results began to trickle down onto the field.
Especially down the stretch when the SF 49ers were still in contention for yet another playoff push but ultimately finished by losing four of their last five games.
Harbaugh was, of course, part of that now-infamous “mutual” parting of ways at the conclusion of the season, which kicked off the rapid demise of what had been one of the most dominating stretches in franchise history.
No. 1: SF 1999 49ers (4-12)
The No. 1 most disappointing season in Niners history is also awfully infamous.
If, for nothing else, because it marked the premature end of a Hall of Famer’s career.
With 2020 marking an injury-riddled campaign as a disappointment, the 1999 season-ending injury suffered by quarterback Steve Young in Week 3 against the Arizona Cardinals on Monday Night Football.
More from SF 49ers All-Time Lists
- Building the greatest 49ers all-time offense in franchise history
- 49ers all-time best NFL Draft picks by each round
- Famous 49ers players who jumped ship and joined Raiders
- 10 tailgate foods (and recipes) 49ers fans should try and will love
- The 10 worst tailgate foods 49ers fans should hate (but don’t)
Young suffered a blindside hit by Cardinals cornerback Aeneas Williams, and that proved to be the last play in the quarterback’s career.
San Francisco was originally projected to get back into the playoffs and potentially make it to the Super Bowl that season. After all, the season before, the SF 49ers finally got over the “playoff hump” by defeating the Green Bay Packers in dramatic fashion. And they boasted two elite wide receivers, Jerry Rice and Terrell Owens, to add to Young’s arsenal.
Instead, Young’s injury prompted the Niners to try getting something out of backup quarterbacks Jeff Garcia and Steve Stenstrom, which didn’t work out well.
While Garcia would eventually have his own success in San Francisco, the SF 49ers lost eight of their following nine games and would finish a disappointing 4-12, marking the first losing season since 1982.
More importantly, the year marked the final time fans saw Young in a Niners uniform.