The San Francisco 49ers have had some pretty impressive rookie seasons in their history. Which ones were the best?
The San Francisco 49ers have hoped over the years their top picks in the NFL Draft pan out to be impact players right away.
Of course, teams always hope that their draft picks will turn around and have great impacts right off the bat, but that’s not always the case. Some draft picks just sputter and entirely fail to launch. See, for example, Kentwan Balmer, Rashaun Woods or Kwame Harris.
Others have great careers, but not a great impact right away. Joe Montana didn’t become the primary starter until his third season, and greats like Jesse Sapolu and Frank Gore didn’t become regular starters right off the bat, either.
Sometimes, young players need time to work their way into the lineup, be it due to lack of opportunity or just adjustments needed to excel at an NFL level.
Other times, however, everything clicks right off the bat, a player hits the ground running and never looks back.
That’s what the 49ers are hoping for from all their rookies each and every season.
Here are the 10 greatest rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history—the group of players each Niners draftee hopes to join.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 10: DT, Bryant Young (1994)
It’s rare that a rookie comes in right off the bat and contributes for a Super Bowl-winning team. In recent years, it’s been limited almost solely to the offensive line—the New England Patriots had center Bryan Stork, the Baltimore Ravens had right tackle Kelechi Osmele and the Green Bay Packers had right tackle Bryan Bulaga. Most Super Bowl teams are so deep that rookies don’t really have a chance to make a big impact off the bat.
Bryant Young bucked that trend out of Notre Dame.
He immediately won a starting job in 1994 next to Dana Stubblefield on the inside, replacing the departed Ted Washington.
Young then responded by being named the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year, recording six sacks and leading the line with 49 tackles as he helped destroy interior offensive lines.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 9: CB, Don Griffin (1986)
Not much was expected out of Don Griffin as a rookie. He was a sixth-round pick out of Middle Tennessee State, drafted more for depth than for anything he was expected to do as a starter off the bat. Griffin wasn’t even a cornerback, playing only one game at the position before he was drafted.
However, the 49ers ended up losing two secondary starters early in the 1986 season, as Dwight Hicks moved on to Indianapolis and All-Pro corner Eric Wright missed all but two games with injuries.
That pushed Griffin into the starting lineup earlier than expected.
Griffin handled his starting roles with aplomb. He had three interceptions, a sack and a punt-return touchdown. He was second on the team with 72 tackles and generally was able to be plugged into a team in the middle of their dynasty without missing a beat.
The 1986 draft was stellar for the 49ers. In addition to Griffin, the 49ers picked up Charles Haley, Steve Wallace, John Taylor and the next man on this list.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 8: CB, Tim McKyer (1986)
A third-round pick out of Texas-Arlington, cornerback Tim McKyer had the difficult task of entering a dynasty in progress and replacing an injured All-Pro in Eric Wright in the starting lineup.
Rookie cornerbacks often struggle against NFL-caliber passing, and throwing someone out to be a starter from day one often leads to early struggles.
McKyer, however, thrived.
Opposing quarterbacks challenged him, but he shrugged them off, recording six interceptions—leading all rookies. He was also the team leader in passes defended with 23—not bad, going up against a schedule that saw him challenged by quarterbacks like Dan Marino, Phil Simms, Jim Everett, Steve DeBerg, Ken O’Brien, Steve Bartowski, Tommy Kramer and Jay Schroeder.
Everett had the hardest time with McKyer, throwing two picks to him in the last game of the regular season to give McKyer the rookie interception crown.
McKyer would have some issues with team management and leave the team after four seasons; he isn’t exactly one of the all-time greats on the team.
As a rookie, though, his blanket coverage and a loudmouth made him an instant contributor.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 7: WR, Jerry Rice (1985)
It’s a little odd to see Hall of Famer Jerry Rice not on top of a 49ers-related list, but his rookie season didn’t get off to an instant stellar start.
Through the first 13 games of the season, in fact, Rice only had 28 catches for 493 yards—a very solid start for a rookie, but not exactly something you would count as being particularly notable. He struggled with drops early on and has admitted since then that he was pressing too much, trying to do too much right off the bat.
He only started four games, behind Dwight Clark and Freddie Solomon.
Then, in December, something just seemed to fall into place. Against the Los Angeles Rams, Rice caught 10 passes for 241 yards, which was at the time a team record and is still fourth-highest in franchise history. He followed that up with 82 and 111-yard days in the final two games of the regular season, and never really looked back. His 927 receiving yards still rank highest in franchise history among pass-catchers.
He was named the NFC’s Offensive Rookie of the Year, and the rest, as they say, is history.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 6: EDGE, Nick Bosa (2019)
The 49ers got the gift of the 2019 NFL Draft when the Arizona Cardinals selected quarterback Kyler Murray No. 1 overall, allowing the Niners to then take perhaps the best overall player in that year’s draft class, Ohio State EDGE Nick Bosa.
Bosa transformed San Francisco’s defense from an underwhelming pass-rushing unit into one of the most formidable that season.
In addition to Bosa racking up nine sacks and terrorizing opposing quarterbacks, he’d go on to earn Defensive Rookie of the Year honors and would become a pinnacle part of the team’s defense in the coming years.
While his sophomore campaign was abbreviated by a season-ending ACL tear, going back to Bosa’s impressive rookie year amid the 49ers’ trip to Super Bowl LIV is nonetheless impressive.
San Francisco got a true steal when Arizona passed on Bosa.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 5: FB, Roger Craig (1983)
Roger Craig split time in the backfield as a rookie. He came in as a fullback next to starting running back Wendell Tyler—but this was an era when fullbacks were very much involved in the running attack, and Craig matched Tyler with 176 carries; it was a true platoon system.
Craig rushed for 725 yards as a rookie with eight touchdowns, but where he really excelled was in the receiving game. Craig was one of the first true dual-threat running backs in the NFL, one of only two men to have more than 1,000 yards rushing and receiving in the same season, and he showed flashes of that as a rookie.
He caught 48 passes for 427 yards and four more touchdowns and ended up leading the team in both yards from scrimmage and rushing/receiving touchdowns. His high-knee rushing style and soft hands immediately turned heads, though it would be a few years before he earned the starting running back slot.
Even though Frank Gore topped his franchise record for rushing yards, Craig’s still a choice for the top back in 49ers history.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 4: FB, Earl Cooper (1980)
While Roger Craig was able to turn his stellar rookie season into a long-term career, Cooper was never really able to duplicate the success he had as a rookie, which goes to show you that one good season does not necessarily mean anything in the long run.
But this isn’t a ranking of “long run.” It’s about rookie seasons, and Cooper’s was great.
He had 83 receptions, second in the NFL behind only Kellen Winslow. He added 720 yards rushing, finishing with 1,287 yards from scrimmage, thriving in the West Coast offense. He really was San Francisco’s top offensive option that year.
Dwight Clark was still young and cracking the starting lineup, and the running back situation was done by committee. Cooper had another solid year the next season and then fell off the map as Roger Craig took over his role as a fullback.
But in that one prelude-to-dynasty year, Cooper looked like he would be the next big thing in the 49ers’ backfield.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 3: FB, Ken Willard (1965)
The 49ers have had some great luck drafting fullbacks; it’s a dying breed, but that’s now three in a row who were able to hit the ground running, if you excuse the pun.
Ken Willard was the second-overall pick in the 1965 draft, so expectations were high for the North Carolina star. He met them immediately. He carried the ball 189 times for 778 yards and five touchdowns, topping 1,000 yards when you add in his receiving numbers. As a rookie, Willard was the fourth-leading rusher in the NFL, behind two Hall of Famers in Jim Brown and Gale Sayers. Willard handled a heavy workload right from the start; only three players had more than his 221 touches as a rookie.
He earned a much-deserved Pro Bowl nod for his work.
A powerful rusher, Willard ended up being one of the 49ers’ key contributors when they reached the NFC Championship in 1970 and 1971, and he retired as the eighth-leading rusher in NFL history.
All that started as a rookie, when Willard showed that he was worth every bit of that second overall pick.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 2: LB Patrick Willis (2007)
Up until now, we’ve been talking about solid players—a couple of Pro Bowl berths here and there, some solid statistics, and some good memories.
Twice, however, the 49ers have drafted a player and seen them immediately establish themselves as the best at their position in the entire league; there’s a rather massive gap between the top two people on this list and everyone else.
Patrick Willis was the No. 11 overall pick out of Mississippi in 2007 and got tutelage from Hall of Famer Mike Singletary as a rookie.
Something rubbed off. Wills led the league with 174 tackles, adding four sacks, two forced fumbles and five passes deflected. He earned Rookie of the Week honors four times and ended up easily winning the Defensive Rookie of the Year award. He was voted as the first-team All-Pro linebacker in 2007 alongside Lofa Tatupu, beating out Nick Barnett and DeMeco Ryans in the process.
Willis made a massive impact from the first time he stepped onto the field, showing the leadership, tenacity and bone-crushing hits that would make him into the best linebacker in the league during his playing career. He entered the league essentially fully formed, already the superstar we grew to knew and love.
It wasn’t the best rookie season, though.
Best rookie seasons in San Francisco 49ers history: No. 1: CB, Ronnie Lott (1981)
We started this list with a 49er who produced for a Super Bowl team as a rookie, and we’re ending it with one, too.
The 49ers defensive secondary was filled with rookies in the 1981 Super Bowl season. Strong safety Carlton Williamson had been taken in the third round. Cornerback Eric Wright had been taken in the second round. Their grizzled veteran was Dwight Hicks at all of 25 years old.
That young secondary should have had growing pains; instead, they thrived on their way to the Super Bowl.
More from Niner Noise
- 49ers 2023 NFL Draft tracker: Pick-by-pick news and analysis
- Predicting 49ers NFL Draft picks by looking at final mocks
- DraftKings NFL Draft Promo – Win $150 Guaranteed on Any $5 Bet
- 2023 NFL Draft: EDGE Byron Young could be impact player for 49ers
- 5 low-key NFL Draft options for 49ers who are flying under the radar
The best of all of them, though, was Ronnie Lott, taken with the eighth overall pick out of USC.
He didn’t win Rookie of the Year honors—that went to Lawrence Taylor—but it was clear from the moment he stepped onto the field at training camp that he was the real deal. He was manhandling receivers with years of experience, getting in their face and making their lives miserable. Lott had seven interceptions, returning three of them for touchdowns, and recovered a couple of fumbles as well.
He was all over the field, instantly proving himself as the most talented defender on the team.
Lott easily was named to the All-Pro team, an honor that would become routine for him. Lott’s Super Bowl win just squeaks past Willis for the top spot, all-time, among 49ers rookies.
One can only hope each year produces rookie talent in the likes of these 10 standouts.