Camp Alex still doesn’t prove Smith the starter


This post was written by Matt Hamm

Alex Smith is organizing a minicamp for 49er offensive players and yes Michael Crabtree is there.  All this may lead to Smith being the 49ers starting QB in 2011.  I still think Jim Harbaugh is and always has been smarter than that.  Alex Smith is organizing a camp with 49er players for one reason and one reason only: the lockout.  The 49ers are stuck with Alex Smith and Alex Smith is stuck with the 49ers.  Think about it, who else right now could “lead” the 49ers offensive players in workouts?  As great as they are there is no way this would work with Vernon Davis or Frank Gore leading the workouts.  You must have a veteran QB and Harbaugh of all people knows that.

Planning for the worst and hoping for the best is solid advice in almost all walks of life including NFL football.  Jim Harbaugh has a new offense to install, a rookie QB to teach, a young offensive line that needs practice together as badly as any unit in the league.  The 49ers as much as any team in the NFL need this practice time.  In a time of uncertainty having Smith in the fold not only allows for some spring practice but gives the 49ers a backup plan if they really do end up needing him to be the starting QB.

Mike Nolan, Mike Singletary, and six offensive coordinators have lost their jobs backing Alex Smith.  Jim Harbaugh a former pro bowl QB himself and proven QB guru in the collegiate ranks will not be just another head coach that gets burnt backing Smith.  Harbaugh has been quoted saying many things praising Smith, enough that the league sent him some hate mail and ordered the 49ers to stop talking about the QB. .

Still when the lockout dust settles the 49ers will make a play for another veteran QB to challenge Smith who will have a clear leg up given his time with the players (and Harbaugh’s playbook).  Look for Carson Palmer, Matt Hasselbeck, Donovan McNabb, Josh Johnson, or Marc Bulger in 49ers training camp competing with Smith for the starting job.

Next 49ers Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep3:25at Dallas CowboysBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Alex Smith Camp Alex San Francisco 49ers

  • Houman Naraghi

    Mike Nolan, Mike Singletary, and four terrible offensive coordinators out of six have turned Alex Smith into Ryan Leaf. This wasn’t the most gifted QB ever, granted, but with those two offensive DOPES as head coaches, he never had a chance.
    Give the guy a break.
    What do you expect from the : run gore inside on first, run gore inside on second, and on 3rd and long HEY ALEX GO BE JOE MONTANA, with only 1 viable option as a recieving TE. EVEN I could game-plan to stop this pathetic predictable offense.
    What are the other options anyway? Papier-machee Marc Bulger? Donovan McNabb? PLEEAASE!!!
    We hired JH because he’s a QB guru, right? Let’s see what he can do to get something out of the #1 overall pick.(Admittedly by default, because noone else wanted the pick that year). But they had drafted Aaron Rodgers, and gave him to those inept coaches, he probably woul’ve ended up the same. Stop harping on Alex, and talk about the TEAM. The Swiss Cheese Secondary, The patchwork inexperienced O-line, and the undersized D-line. It starts there. Fix the Lines and even Trent Dilfer can win a superbowl.