Alex Smith Named Starter Against the Colts


Alex Smith named the starter

Alex Smith named the starter

Now I can see why it took Mike Singletary so long to make a decision in training camp about the 49ers starting quarterback.  Singletary named long forgotten and former number one draft pick Alex Smith as the starter against the Colts on Sunday.  In the back of his mind he probably had Smith as the starter all along but went with the proven quarterback Shaun Hill who is 8-6 as a starter for the Niners.  Singletary made the announcement yesterday on October 26.  Last year on October 26 in Singletary’s first game as interim head coach he pulled quarterback J.T. O’Sullivan out of the game against the Seahawks and put in Hill who started the rest of the season and up until week seven of this year.  Is there something about the week before Halloween that makes Singletary feel as if he needs to make a change at quarterback?  I wonder what he will do next year?  Joking aside, making a quarterback change on the same day as you did last year is not a sign of Singletary being erratic with who should start as the quarterback but a sign that the organization is erratic in trying to find a starting quarterback that can be successful in the NFL and lead a powerful offense.

The peaks and valleys that has been Alex Smith’s career is at about its third peak after years of being stuck down in the valley.  Watching Smith run the 49ers offense and pass for three touchdowns against the Texans I was more concerned about the 49ers winning the game than who was under center.  After watching the 49ers lose I was able to take it all in and realized that Smith who had not played in the regular season since November 12, 2007 had just showed that the 49ers do have a passing game.  With Smith’s success and Singletary known for wanting to put the best 11 players on the field that he believes gives the team the best chance to win, see Michael Crabtree, I was almost certain that Singletary would name Smith the starter.  Coming to that conclusion and hearing the news this morning I am still nervous about Smith being named the QB.

Reasons to be worried:

  • Smith did come into the game against the Texans down by 21 points and almost lead the team to a comeback win.  But how much of that was the Texans defense coming out after half-time and taking off the third quarter thinking they had the game won especially with a backup quarterback inserted into the game?
  • With the 49er down by three touchdowns offensive coordinator Jimmy Raye went away from running the football and was forced to pass to lessen the deficit.  Raye had Smith mostly running the spread offense which Smith is clearly comfortable with as he ran the same offense while at the University of Utah.  With running back Frank Gore back in the lineup after missing three games with an injury I doubt Raye will deviate away from his run, run, run mentality but with Smith as the starter he might want to call more plays in the spread offense formation to make Smith effective against the Colts defense.
  • The 49ers offensive line is a wreck on the right side and it showed against the Texans.  Without stone foot Shaun Hill dropping back in the second-half the line did improve their play as Smith did not get sacked but that has more to do with Smith’s scrambling abilities than the play of the line.  Smith will be running often against the Colts as the defense will look to get after Smith who will be making his first start in almost two years.
  • It will be interesting to see how Smith plays for a full game.  Smith has been called a cerebral quarterback but has been criticized for thinking too much which resulted in sacks and bad decisions. As Smith found his team down by three scores he had to score as quickly as possible which left no time for Smith to think about the play too much and rely on his instincts which were right on almost all of the plays expect for his last pass which was intercepted and ended the game.  I am not sure how Smith will handle running a normal offense that is not in hurry up mode to try to quickly score.

Reason to be excited:

  • Even though Alex Smith was drafted in 2005 he is only 25 years old.  That is young by NFL QB standards so I can see why the 49ers held onto Smith knowing his potential and knowing that his first four seasons in the NFL have been a bumping road.  Smith was named the starter half way through his rookie season in 2005, took all the snaps under center in 2006, played hurt for seven games in 2007, was on injured reserve in 2008 and was a backup through the first seven weeks of the season this year.  Most quarterbacks stay on the bench for their first two to three years learning the offense and adjusting to the NFL and find success once on the field (see Aaron Rodgers, Carson Palmer).  Smith found himself on a horrible 49ers team looking for anyone to play center and was forced out onto the field.  Unless you are Peyton Manning most starting rookie quarterbacks don’t mature into long NFL careers.  Smith has now had his time to learn and regain his confidence.  Hopefully he can translate all of his knowledge into a successful offense.
  • After two straight games where the defense was the main reason for the losses which in turn made the offense anemic forcing them to try to come back from big deficits maybe this is the type of change the 49ers offense needs.  Shaun Hill did his job in managing the game and ran the offense well while they were ahead or down by a few points but when it came time for the offense to comeback and score Hill could not get the job done. Smith showed he can remain calm under pressure situations when down by a big deficit.
  • One of the reasons for Smith being named the starter was that he was impressive in training camp and continued impressing in practice.  Both don’t count and are meaningless but Singletary knows what Smith is capable of doing and he showed that against the Texans.  Smith also sacrificed more than $16 million to remain with the Niners to prove not only to himself but to the organization that drafted him, the 49er Faithful and to all of those, including me, who wrote him off as another number one pick draft bust.

Now is your time to shine Alex, the 49er Faithful wait for you to change our minds about what you are capable of doing on the field.  Let’s hope he gets things started on Sunday against the Colts and ends the 49ers two game losing streak.

Alex Smith is...

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Next 49ers Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep3:25at Dallas CowboysBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: 49ers 49ers 2009 Season 49ers Offensive Coordinator 49ers QB 49ers Quarterback 49ers Training Camp Alex Smith Alex Smith Named Starter Against The Colts Frank Gore J.T. O'Sullivan Jimmy Raye Michael Crabtree Mike Singletary San Francisco 49ers Scot McCloughan Shaun Hill

  • http://NinerNoise Lincoln Commissioner

    The failure, either schematic or personnel or both, of the offensive line has made a power running game impossible and grossly retarded the development of Alex Smith and, now, Shaun Hill. Until this unit is a functioning unit, we will NOT KNOW what level of potential Smith, Hill or any other quarterback possesses. The answer is that simple, but that DIFFICULT. Offensive lines take time, personnel, time, scheme, and time to develop.
    I find it worthwhile rooting for two respectful and team oriented quarterbacks. The past years could have easily produced much turmoil with lesser men.

  • Jackalope

    I would like to humbly disagree with both the article and I feel as though it stems from your method of analysis. You are looking at one game as a microcosm for Alex Smith’s career rather than looking at it as a progression. Also, you are looking at the game itself all wrong in my point of view. First, WHY would the Texans defense “take off the third quarter” because they were up at half time. Have you ever seen a proud defense, which the Texans most definitely are, relax when they have a potential shut-out on their hands. I understand if the 49ers scored one touchdown in the waning minutes of the 4th quarter, yeah, sure, you can call that a lack in push. But coming out and scoring and moving the ball like he did, absolutely not. Second, in what crazy parallel universe is it easier to throw when the defense knows you have to throw. Saying that becoming one dimensional is a key to success is ludicrous. Again, late in the 4th in a run away game when the defense is hanging back waiting for a big play… sure. But Alex Smith marched the 49ers to pay-dirt in 3 of the first 4 drives of the second half. It’s not like the Texans were in prevent. If anything the Texans had a huge advantage. They knew Alex had to throw because the 49ers couldn’t execute sustained drives if they really wanted to win. Lastly, being a cerebral quarterback has always been a strength of his and it is short-sighted to say it has ever been a negative. He has had 4 offensive coordinators and never a true mentor to teach him about the speed and differences in the NFL game. In his first 4 years, when he wasn’t injured, he was surrounded by one of the worst patch-work offensive lines in the league, an abysmal WR core, and the only bright spot was a young running back that was limited in success after a break-out year because of an terrible offensive line and another change in offensive coordination. I don’t want to make excuses for Alex, and I don’t want to commit to him being the next big thing, but I think your analysis of his second half against the Texans was way off. He deserves support and better than what you delivered. Sounds familiar.

  • Pingback: Orlando Magic News & Notes: The Season is Finally Here, Links From Around the World of Sports | Howard the Dunk | An Orlando Magic Blog